Clean energy journalism for a cooler tomorrow

Senate OKs permitting bill that would boost clean and dirty energy

After years of struggling to pass reforms, the Senate has finally sent a bipartisan package to the House. But the bill has divided decarbonization advocates.
By Dan McCarthy

  • Link copied to clipboard
From left, Sen. Mike Lee (R-Utah), Sen. Shelley Moore Capito (R-W.Va.), Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.), and Sen. Martin Heinrich (D-N.M.) hold a news conference on the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act in the U.S. Capitol on Sept. 30, 2026. (Bill Clark/CQ-Roll Call, Inc via Getty Images)

A bipartisan bill that would make it easier to build energy infrastructure — both dirty and clean — has passed the Senate by a 62 to 33 vote.

The sprawling Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act would streamline permitting for energy and infrastructure projects by enacting significant changes to federal environmental regulations and introducing new policy mechanisms around data centers and the transmission grid. It would also provide developers with greater protections once a project is greenlit.

The House of Representatives will now take up the legislation, which was co-written by Democratic Sens. Martin Heinrich (N.M.) and Sheldon Whitehouse (R.I.) — two vocal supporters of clean energy — and Republican Sens. Mike Lee (Utah) and Shelley Moore Capito (W.Va.). The bill’s supporters aim to pass the current version now, while it has bipartisan momentum, rather than risk holding out for a better deal under the Democratic-led Congress next year. 

Analysts widely expect that the legislation would accelerate the deployment of renewable energy — already the nation’s fastest-growing source of electricity. Critically, the bill would also help speed up the construction of transmission lines, which are needed to bring new energy generation online but notoriously difficult and slow to build in America. It would also ease permitting for fossil-fueled power plants, pipelines, and data centers. 

The bipartisan bill has attracted a wide coalition of supporters that includes utility and fossil fuel groups as well as the clean-energy industry and many decarbonization advocates. But several major environmental groups, including the Sierra Club and the Natural Resources Defense Council, have come out against the legislation. A number of tribal groups have voiced concerns as well. Most Democratic senators ultimately voted against the bill.

Within the climate world, the key point of disagreement is whether the bill would drive an increase or a reduction in planet-warming emissions. 

Different models have arrived at different conclusions. Energy analysis firm Rhodium Group has found that the bill would cause greenhouse gas emissions to fall. Think tank Resources for the Future also predicts it would reduce emissions. But other energy modelers have found the bill would spur so much construction of fossil fuel infrastructure that it would cause emissions to rise. 

Despite the difficulty in projecting the bill’s impact, climate-minded supporters of the legislation say the U.S. energy transition can’t happen without major changes to federal permitting processes like those included in the bill. 

Power lines offer a bracing example. The U.S. must double to triple its current transmission capacity to decarbonize the power grid by the mid-2030s, according to a study from Princeton University’s Repeat Project, but the pace of power line construction remains sluggish. Experts widely agree that the bill would accelerate the grid buildout.

Nevertheless, the bill’s opponents — many of whom support faster construction of clean energy and transmission — say it would give too much away to the fossil fuel industry. In particular, they warn that the bill’s modifications to the Federal Power Act, Clean Water Act, Endangered Species Act, and National Environmental Policy Act would let bad actors ram through fossil fuel and data center projects. They also fear that the Trump administration would continue to attack renewable energy projects even with the new law in place. 

Opponents are now hoping the House, where Republicans hold a slim majority, will block the measure. 

“While a rogue president is waging a war on clean energy, the Senate rushed a deeply flawed bill that furthers the buildout of fossil fuels, strips away power from communities and Tribes, threatens our clean water and public lands, and endangers wildlife,” said Sierra Club Executive Director Loren Blackford in a statement, adding that the House ​“must reject the Senate’s fast-tracked bill and demand debate and consideration to deliver for the people, not corporate polluters and Donald Trump.”

Permitting reform has been a live discussion for years, but over and over again, legislation has stalled out. This is the first time in recent years that a permitting reform bill has passed the Senate. Decarbonization advocates who support the bill argue that this is the best chance to enact reforms that are necessary for the energy transition — even if it requires some significant trade-offs.

Lena Moffitt, executive director of Evergreen Action, a climate advocacy group that’s come out in favor of the permitting bill, acknowledged in a statement that the legislation ​“includes many painful compromises,” but nevertheless her group is urging the House to pass it, too. 

“For years, our broken permitting system has stalled the power lines, clean energy projects, and public transit that make life more affordable,” she said. ​“While no single bill will solve the climate crisis or cost of living crisis on its own, this one will help us build cheap, clean energy faster and at scale and open the floodgates to the climate solutions we know are needed to save millions of lives.”

This signup form requires necessary cookies.

Allow marketing cookies to load the newsletter signup form.

Dan McCarthy is a senior editor at Canary Media.